Ricky Spanish and his stepsister Haley Reed have an interesting relationship, where they constantly flirt with one another. When Haley's mom leaves the house, Haley winks at Ricky and then goes to change into tight yoga pants that show off her ass and camel toe. Ricky's dick, Mr. Johnson, narrates the whole scenario, right down to how badly Ricky wants to tap that but won't out of fear that Haley will rat him out. After a few stretches, Haley goes to take a shower. The imagery of that doesn't do a thing to make Mr. Johnson stop wanting to fuck.
Madison Summers and Scarlet Skies are hanging out, but it's a boring day. Scarlet suggests they go to the mall, but Madison can't because her mom is insisting she make a cake for her stepbrother's birthday to help them get along better. Madison really dislikes her stepbrother, Codey Steele, because he's always pranking her. In fact, Madison has an idea of how to get back at Codey. The girls peel off their clothes and put on aprons for some almost-naked cake making. They make a huge mess and have lots of fun doing it! Codey walks in just as the cake is ready and is super flattered that the girls have thought of him. He's not expecting it when they say they have another surprise for him.
Madison Summers has been hooking up with her stepbrother's best friend. Joshua Lewis isn't exactly in the dark. He tries to let Madison know that he knows when he catches her early in the morning doing the walk of shame, but Madison takes the easy way out and claims she has to go to bed. She feels badly about it, though, so later that day she corners Joshua in his room so she can come clean to him. Her idea of an apology is to describe her sexcapades with Joshua's best friend in as much detail as she spreads her thighs and masturbates in Joshua's face.
Kyle Mason has long wanted his stepsister Andi Rose, but this Christmas he's about to see that wishes do come true. Their adventure starts with Andi doing some Christmas crafts at the table. Kyle is creeping on her, as is his usual, but this time Andi is ready for him. She asks him to help with her craft and Kyle comes back saying of course he will on the condition Andi shows him her tits. Andi doesn't think twice; she flashes those lovely boobies in Kyle's direction and then goes back to work. What is Kyle supposed to do besides help his stepsis out and check her out at every opportunity now that he knows what her breasts and tight little nipples look like beneath her shirt?
Juan Loco and his stepsister Lily Larimar are constantly bickering. This time, they're fighting in front of Lily's friend Braylin Bailey because Juan wants to see Lily's cell phone. Eventually Braylin tries to broker a deal by pointing out that Lily has been saying Juan is a really cool stepbrother and Lily should let him look unless she has something to hide. Juan comes back by saying he'll let Lily look at the dick pics on his phone if he can see hers. Still in the middle, Braylin takes Lily's phone and goes through her messages to see that Lily's two biggest fantasies are to be hogtied and to be DP'ed. Lily also wants to get with her stepbrother. Braylin then goes through Juan's phone and finds the promised dick pics. The girls like what they see.
